Light Rail Transit in Dhaka
By Dr. Md. Masud Karim
Dainichi Consultant Inc., Gifu,
Japan.
Bangladesh is a populous country and Dhaka, as the capital of Bangladesh,
has to accommodate a large share of this population. There are 18 Special
Planning Zones (SPZ) in the Dhaka Metropolitan Area, where population has
already crossed 10 million. With a rate of increase of population at about
7% per year, Dhaka Metropolitan Area is expected to become one of the largest
cities within the early next century. The city centre of Dhaka is located
on the bank of the river Buriganga. The city is growing at a rate of 4.5
km2 a year. As of 1992, there are about 8567350 daily trips by different
modes (walk, road, and water transport) and 2397926 working places in 18
SPZs. The contribution of Bangladesh Railways (BR) to urban public transport
is very small. The main inter city line entering the city from the north
carries a small share of commuter traffic. The line to Narayanganj recently
handed over to private management shows a greater efficiency in carrying
huge back and forth commuter traffic. Rehabilitation and improvement of
north main BR line and some new routes of rail transit can accommodate
the growing traffic demand in the near future. This article is going to
make discussions on the feasibility of Light Rail Transit (LRT) network
for Dhaka Metropolitan area.
The Present Traffic System
The transportation system of Dhaka is predominantly road based where
non-motorized transportation (mainly rickshaw) has a substantial share.
Dhaka Metropolis has heterogeneous traffic flows, as of 1996 an estimated
168,718 automobiles are on road. Rickshaws are the dominating mode of public
transport. Around 80% of total trips in Dhaka City is comprised of non-motorized
transport (NMT), only 5.9% trips are made by motorized transport (MT),
and average trip lengths of NMT and MT are 18 and 27 minutes, respectively
(Karim, et. al. 1998). Trips made by public transport especially buses
are very low, only 0.9%. A substantial part of total traffic is non-motorized
vehicles which enhance severe congestion especially in road intersections.
Among the total trips about 43% are made using rickshaw and have been increasing
continuously over the last 20 years. The cost of transport represents about
10.8% of total household incomes.
In Dhaka Metropolitan Area, as of 1992 about 3094813 trips are made
by public transport daily. Of them, about 1636898 trips are made with rickshaw,
251303 with auto-rickshaw, 69310 with auto-tempo, 2752 with existing rails,
284634 trips by water transport, and 693163 with the buses. The number
of passengers in public transport has been increasing continuously over
the last 20 years. However, there is a clear difference in the share of
public transport trips to the city according to the corridor in question.
The shares of public transport trips are higher from the south than from
the north. The main reason to this is the socioeconomic status of the inhabitants
of the areas. The people in northern part of Dhaka have higher income and
higher car ownership than the people in southern part of Dhaka.
The Problem
From the experience of other megacities, it can be said that road network
alone can not satisfy the need for transportation of such a large city.
However, the road network of Dhaka City is non-lane basis and all transport
modes (motorized and non-motorized) use the same lane. Even at very small
percentage of motorized vehicles (less than 5 motorized vehicle per 1000
people) the city dwellers are experiencing severe congestion everywhere
in the city in all the working hours. There exist severe air and noise
pollution caused by motor vehicles and a very high accident rate. Overcrowding,
air and noise pollution, adequate nutrition, and other deficiencies in
the physical environment frequently represent the most obvious manifestations
of environmental health problems. However, there are less visible problems
of the social environment, which should also be identified such as: differentials
in mortality among urban residents from non-communicable diseases such
as heart disease and cancer are related to social rather than the physical
environment within the society.
Besides being the capital of a highly populous country, Dhaka has a
major role to play in the era of regional and sub-regional cooperation,
which are being contemplated recently. However, the existing transportation
system may become bottleneck for the development of the city. To maintain
the economic viability of this City and to keep its environment sustainable,
an efficient transportation system is imperative.
Traditionally it was argued that transport exerted a strong positive
influence on economic development and that increased production could be
directly related to improved transport. Transport can release working capital
from one area, which can be used more productively as fixed capital elsewhere
(Button 1993). The inadequacy of transport facilities is one of the major
bottlenecks to socioeconomic development of the major cities and a national
integration. Often the lack of transport makes it difficult to introduce
other social infrastructure such as education and medical service. Transport
investment forms a major component of the capital formation of the developing
countries and expenditure on transport is usually the largest single item
in the national budget. Up to 40 per cent of public expenditure should
be devoted to transport infrastructure investment with substantial supplements
coming from outside international agencies such as the World Bank, UN,
and other development aid agencies.
To cope with the problems of increasing transportation demand, traffic
congestion, deteriorating environmental quality, and inadequate traffic
safety measures Light Rail Transit can be a probable solution. LRT is a
modern and somewhat modified version of the traditional tramway. It has
been introduced in some developing cities on the ground that it can offer
a high capacity service with an appealing modern image, it is less expensive
than full subway system, and it is environmentally friendly. Considering
its potential, LRT may be proved a suitable solution to the present transportation
need of Dhaka City. The government of Bangladesh is taking positive measures
for commuter rail in Dhaka. It is now a matter of gearing up on an agenda
to a sustainable transportation system for the next century.
Dhaka's Traffic Pollution
In recent years, the frequency of environmental problems in Bangladesh
and other countries has increased substantially, causing serious damage
to lives and property. The most crucial questions that need to be addressed
are: what really causes the havoc-creating environmental problems, the
economic estimates of pollution effects on society, the possible solution
of air pollution, and the social and infrastructure development to improve
the quality of the city dwellers.
In whole Bangladesh, the number of motor vehicles per 1000 people rose
from 1.4 in 1982 to 2.28 in 1991, and 2.72 in 1995 (BBS, 1995). Nearly
one third of motor vehicles are operated by diesel (truck, bus), which
contribute a greater portion of urban SPM, SOx, and NOx, sometimes private
cars are energized using a proportion of (3:2) gasoline and diesel. Pollution
severity occur due to the high content of lead in gasoline, large number
of high polluting vehicles, impure fuel, inefficient landuse, and overall
poor traffic management (Karim et al, 1997). Major issues are the heterogeneous
flows of traffic and two stroke engines moving in Dhaka's street which
emit greater proportion of black smoke. Another dominating factor of Dhaka's
traffic pollution is the number of auto-rickshaw and tempo. Their increase
is most remarkable in Dhaka where the proportion of such two-stroke vehicles
in the total vehicle population rose from 2.2% in 1982-83, to 18% in 1990-91
and as high as 23% in 1996-97 (Karim et al, 1997). It is not out of subject
to mention here that the two-stroke engines (auto-rickshaw) moving in Dhaka
City are simple modified forms of an Italian model of 1960's which emits
30 times more pollution than a normal car (Karim, 1997).
Conclusion
It is quite difficult to imagine that basic transport services can be
provided for a metropolis with 10 million people without reliable mass
transit system. Changes in transport technology, have over time, exerted
a strong influence upon the shapes and forms of the urban areas. It is,
at the same time, true that although transport demand requires the development
of rail mass transit system, financial restraints normally rejects the
option and sometimes economic reason asks for better alternative solutions.
|